How to Pick a Classic Engagement Ring | For A Timeless Look

When it comes to choosing an engagement ring, there’s a lot of pressure to find something special. You want a ring that’ll make them gasp, feel weak in the knees, and maybe shed a tear (or two). But you also want something that won't go out of style when the next jewelry trend hits Instagram. So, how do you pick a classic engagement ring that will stand the test of time, making your proposal memorable now and 30 years down the road?

Here’s where classic ring designs come in. They are the little black dress of engagement rings—always elegant, never out of place, and timelessly stylish. Let’s explore how to pick a ring that whispers “forever” without shouting, “I’m trying too hard.”

milana round lab created diamond engagement ring

Traditional Engagement Rings: Why Reinvent the Wheel?

There’s a reason why traditional engagement rings have stuck around for centuries—they simply work. They’re like the chocolate chip cookie of jewelry: reliable, universally loved, and no one’s going to turn one down. These rings tend to feature timeless ring designs that have proven themselves as elegant, durable, and beautiful across generations.


Think of a simple solitaire ring, for instance. It’s the definition of “less is more,” with one stone (often a diamond) taking center stage. A classic ring setting like this showcases the brilliance of the gem without overwhelming it with too much detail. The beauty of a traditional design is that it focuses on the basics: great stone, elegant band, and a look that’s effortlessly chic.

ruby round lab created diamond engagement ring

Timeless Ring Designs: The Magic is in the Details

While traditional rings keep things simple, there are plenty of options to explore when it comes to timeless ring designs. A design that’s stood the test of time doesn’t mean boring. Classic rings can include beautiful details like pave bands (a thin line of diamonds on the band), or the ever-romantic halo design, which surrounds the center stone with a circle of smaller diamonds, giving it extra sparkle.

These kinds of rings manage to be timeless by not veering too far into the trends of the moment. A good rule of thumb? If it looks like something you’d see on a royal hand—or Audrey Hepburn’s—it’s probably a timeless choice.

victoria oval lab created diamond engagement ring

Classic Ring Settings: Where Function Meets Style

Next up: the setting. Just as important as the stone itself, classic ring settings are what hold your gemstone in place. But don’t worry, it’s not all about functionality—settings also play a huge role in the overall design.

The prong setting is the MVP here. With four or six prongs holding the stone, it allows light to hit the lab-created diamond from multiple angles, maximizing the sparkle (and, let’s be honest, who doesn’t want a little extra bling?). This setting is an essential part of classic ring designs because it highlights the beauty of the stone without overshadowing it. Plus, it's as secure as it is stunning, keeping that precious gem safe for all the anniversaries to come.

Another popular classic ring setting is the bezel, which encircles the stone with a thin metal rim. It offers a sleeker, modern twist while still maintaining that timeless vibe. For those with a more active lifestyle (or who tend to be a bit clumsy, no judgment here!), the bezel setting offers a more secure option while still looking chic.

rachel radiant moissanite bezel engagement ring

Classic Ring Designs: Stones That Shine

Diamonds may be forever, but they’re not your only option. While diamonds are the most popular stone for timeless ring styles, moissanite is quickly becoming a star in its own right. With nearly the same sparkle as a diamond and an attractive price tag, moissanite is a perfect fit for anyone who wants the look of a traditional ring with a little something extra.

When considering classic ring designs, think about your partner’s personality and style. Do they love simplicity? Go for a solitaire. Want a little more flair? The halo design is perfect. Whether you choose a diamond or moissanite, make sure it’s a stone that’ll shine as bright as your love (cue the awws).

angelina cushion cut lab created diamond engagement ring

Timeless Ring Styles: Elegance That Never Ages

Finally, let’s talk about timeless ring styles. A classic ring doesn’t need to be fancy or over-the-top; in fact, the best ones rarely are. It’s all about balance and elegance. A thin band with a single stone, an understated pave setting, or a three-stone ring all capture the essence of timelessness.

The key to picking a ring with a timeless ring style is to ask yourself: will I love this ring 20, 30, or even 50 years from now? If the answer is yes, then you’ve found your match—not just in the ring, but in life too.

 leah cushion cut moissanite with pear shape lab diamonds engagement ring

So, go ahead, choose that engagement ring with confidence. Just remember: trends come and go, but a classic ring is forever. And isn’t that what this whole engagement thing is about anyway?